Is this portfolio’s volatility right for you? What is your probability of success? Many client conversations start with questions like these. While reasonable, they have an important problem: talking about risk is not the same thing as preparing for bad outcomes.
Clients do not experience risk as volatility or as a probability. They experience risk when markets crash and their lifestyle suddenly appears unaffordable, or after losing a job while needing to cover mortgage payments and fund college for the kids.
There is an opportunity for advisors to shift the conversation from risk tolerance to risk management. Liability‑driven investing is a useful starting point, and it offers an alternative to volatility‑based approaches to portfolio construction.
Used for decades by pensions and insurers as an immunization strategy, liability‑driven investing and its principles also apply to private clients. Compared to a pension fund, private clients have a broader hierarchy of needs, resources and preferences. Liability‑driven investing is therefore most effective when paired with a comprehensive wealth management framework that considers the client’s full financial picture — not just the investment portfolio.
The Limits Of Risk Tolerance
Imagine a client camping beside a lake with changing water levels. One camps far from shore; another camps near the water, accepting a greater risk of flooding. A traditional risk‑tolerance conversation asks how close to the water the client is comfortable camping.
The problem is that comfort with risk does not prepare the camper for different water levels. A more robust solution is to stay in a boat. The boat rises and falls with the water rather than depending on the selection of the right patch of ground.
Rather than ask where to camp, liability‑driven investing asks what needs to float.
A Hierarchy Of Outcomes
To apply this approach, advisors can organize a client’s objectives into a priority hierarchy:
- Essential objectives are the client’s non‑negotiables, such as food, shelter and other basic needs.
- Important objectives are lifestyle expenses, such as travel, entertainment and education.
- Discretionary objectives are nice‑to‑have but not critical to well‑being, such as charitable giving and spending on hobbies.
This hierarchy gives advisors a basis for evaluating how different assets best support different objectives. Essential objectives require a high degree of reliability, whereas important and discretionary objectives can often accept more risk in pursuit of portfolio growth, as these objectives can be downsized if conditions disappoint. For example:
- A liability‑driven fixed income portfolio can help protect essential objectives.
- A balanced public market portfolio can support important objectives.
- Private assets, alternative investments and other nontraditional assets can fund discretionary objectives.
The more a client considers essential, the more they need to protect, and the more fixed income may be required in their portfolio. Therefore, a central strategic component is helping clients size their essential objectives to balance the tradeoff between risk protection and aggregate expected return.
Ultimately, risk‑taking becomes less a personality trait and more an intentional funding decision tied to the client’s chosen level of protection and the characteristics of their desired outcomes.
Ultimately, risk‑taking becomes less a personality trait and more an intentional funding decision.
How To Build A Liability‑Driven Fixed Income Portfolio
This approach to risk management changes how advisors talk about bonds, which are often presented as a way to reduce portfolio volatility when equities decline. That framing is not wrong, but it is limited. Instead of focusing on volatility, liability‑driven bond portfolios are designed to provide protection and liquidity for specific future spending needs.
To build a liability‑driven bond portfolio, advisors can start by determining which future spending liabilities need to be funded by bonds:
- Determine the client’s total desired spending.
- Separate essential spending from flexible spending.
- Identify how much essential spending is already covered by Social Security and other protective resources.
- Use bonds to fund the remaining essential spending gap.
This process results in a tailored asset allocation that reflects the client’s spending needs and recognizes how much is already protected. This base layer of protection provides confidence to take more risk with the rest of the client’s investment portfolio and broader wealth.
The Portfolio Is Only Part Of The Boat
A client’s investment portfolio is just one piece of the puzzle. The broader financial structure can also include real estate, mortgages, private assets, business interests, future earnings, Social Security, pensions, insurance payouts and expected inflows. Some components provide liquidity, some offer protection, and some help hedge inflation. Others introduce concentration, leverage or limited accessibility.
A client’s investment portfolio is just one piece of the puzzle.
This broader view changes the role of the liquid portfolio. Rather than treating it as a standalone solution, advisors can treat it as flexible capital within the client’s full financial structure. It can provide liquidity, support essential needs, fund growth where objectives are flexible and offset exposures already embedded in a career, business, property or balance sheet.
This approach places the advisor in a broader wealth architect role. The work extends beyond simulations and investment selection — it connects the purpose of the client’s wealth with assets, liabilities, income sources, insurance, taxes, liquidity and preferences.
Designing For Resilience
Liability‑driven investing does not remove uncertainty, but it can change how uncertainty affects the client’s life. By organizing wealth around the outcomes it is intended to fund, this framework can reduce reliance on any single forecast or assumption and provide a better‑informed basis for decisions.
For advisors who already believe portfolios should be built around what clients need their money to do, liability‑driven investing provides structure and language to put that belief into practice.
Jorge Tarraso is Head of Client Experience at Libretto, a provider of financial planning and portfolio management technology for RIAs and family offices.