Dear Ryan,
We just had our best year in firm history. AUM crossed $3.1 billion. Revenue is up 34% over three years. We added nine advisors. By every number that gets reported to our board, we are winning.
I should feel good about that. But mostly I feel something closer to dread.
Three weeks ago one of our best advisors sat down with me and said he’d accepted an offer from another firm. Not a competitor chasing him with a bigger payout — a smaller shop with half our AUM and, in his words, “an operations team that actually has his back.” I asked him what that meant. He said for two years he’s been doing his own paperwork follow‑up, chasing his own compliance flags and rebuilding client reports by hand because our systems couldn’t be trusted to get them right the first time.
I asked why he didn’t say something sooner. He said he tried twice. Both times the response was some version of “we’re a little stretched right now but it’s a good problem to have.”
A good problem to have. That’s a corporate jargon version of “these are not the droids you are looking for.” I’ve said that sentence myself. More than once.
Once he said it out loud to me, I started looking differently at things I’d been explaining away for too long. Technically, our onboarding process works, but only because three people are manually catching things that should be automated, and none of them have said no to the overtime yet. Our compliance team is current on policy and quietly terrified of the pace. We’ve hired nine advisors and promoted exactly one operations person. Every uncomfortable staffing conversation got deferred because the topline growth number looked too good to argue with.
Here’s the thing though: None of this shows up anywhere. Not in the board materials, not in the advisor or client satisfaction survey, not in a single metric anyone is tracking. The market has been generous for three years, and that generosity has been quietly subsidizing every operational shortcut we’ve taken.
The market has been generous for three years, and that generosity has been quietly subsidizing every operational shortcut we’ve taken.
I don’t know what happens to this firm in a year where the market isn’t doing us a favor. I’m not sure I want to find out by accident.
How do I make my partners, and honestly myself, take this seriously when every number in front of us says we’ve never been stronger?
— Winning On Paper, Worried Underneath
Dear Winning On Paper, Worried Underneath,
Your advisor just told you something that should scare you more than the $3.1 billion comforts you. Growth alone won’t keep your firm healthy. It’s evidence of demand. Those are different things, and your firm has been quietly treating one as proof of the other for what appears to be several years.
Here’s a simple test: Could your firm survive a flat year? Not a bad year, a flat one. No market tailwind, no easy AUM growth, nothing covering for the gaps. If the honest answer is that your operations, your staffing and your processes would be exposed the moment the market stopped doing you a favor, you don’t have a strong firm. You have a strong market and a firm that’s been riding it.
Your departing advisor already ran this test for you. He didn’t leave because of money. He just did the math and stacked up what two more years of “a good problem to have” would cost him personally, and jumped ship before the bill came due. That’s not disloyalty. That’s the most honest feedback your firm has received in years. And it came from someone who had every reason to stay quiet and couldn’t.
The most dangerous part of your situation isn’t the gaps themselves. Every growing firm has gaps. The dangerous part is that your growth number is a smoke screen. It’s actively preventing your partners from seeing the cracks, because nobody wants to be the person raising “big picture” concerns during the best year in firm history.
Don’t bring your partners a list of problems. You’ve got to change the conversation. Bring them the flat year test. Ask them directly: If growth stopped tomorrow, what breaks first? This way you turn perceived worries into real‑time risks.
You already know what would break first. You just listed it in your letter.
Go fix it while you still have the revenue to pay for it.
— Ryan
Ryan George is the Chief of Staff of Docupace.